• For our 10th anniversary on May 9th, 2024, we will be giving out 15 GB of free, off-shore, DMCA-resistant file storage per user, and very possibly, public video hosting! For more details, check a look at our roadmap here.

    Welcome to the edge of the civilized internet! All our official content can be found here. If you have any questions, try our FAQ here or see our video on why this site exists at all!

Cinema Ghost in the Shell (1995) - A Groundbreaking Movie With a Few Blemishes

Arnox

Master
Staff member
Founder
Messages
5,285
Rating
4.00 star(s)
Ghost in the Shell may not have started the cyberpunk genre at all, but when evaluating what would be the most influential cyberpunk... Nay, the most influential sci-fi movies of all time, it's pretty damn hard to pass up this movie. It's inspired many many works since its release from The Matrix to (James Cameron's) Avatar to Perfect Dark to even Bungie's obscure title, Oni. Probably only Blade Runner has been more influential in the sci-fi cinema space.

From a technical standpoint, this movie still holds up pretty well, featuring the same gorgeous attention to detail that distinguished Cowboy Bebop. Sound design is a bit generic but otherwise fits the scenes pretty damn well. The voicework though... This is where we come to one of the first blemishes with the film. At times, the voice lines quite literally feel like they're being read off a piece of paper in a flat and sort of hurried manner and it does a lot to break immersion. And don't get me wrong. Sometimes, that's exactly the line delivery that's needed for some characters, but for others, it makes no sense at all.

There's also a fair few times where the shot just kind of... Lingers just a little too long, making it kinda eyebrow raising. Ok, the characters have spoken their lines for this scene. Why is the "camera" lingering over them for an extra three or so seconds in a still shot? And the awkwardness can be further exacerbated by the deliberate (but actually pretty good in the end) decision to make the cyborg characters have larger eyes that do not blink ever, adding an uncanny valley effect sometimes too. With that said, it does make sense that the cyborgs are deliberately made to appear artificial and slightly uncanny looking. This is an excellently subtle way to signal to the audience that these characters aren't quite human without having to pull out a megaphone and announce it every time.

The last problem I think it has is the usual annoyance I seem to see a lot these days where characters make bafflingly stupid decisions. And this time, the Retard Decision award goes to the Major (and also Bato) for putting aside common sense and hooking themselves up to a notorious government cyberweapon with barely any semblance of protection. You really fucking thought that one through, didn't you. >_>

Let's put all that aside though and begin talking about why this movie is really good. For one the combat scenes are decent enough and the plot is pretty tight. The governmental intrigue gets kind of hard to track at times, and I'll be honest, sometimes I just couldn't keep up, but it's not really necessary in the end as the main thread is relatively simple to understand. The soundtrack is pretty good as well. At first watch, it may seem discordant with the gritty sci-fi surroundings, but despite that, the movie succeeds at being kind of... Dreamy. It's a very cool feeling and pretty appropriate to the themes the movie is going for. This surrealness is also helped by the, for lack of better words, technological beauty of the Major. Thinking about it, I keep coming to a key question brought up in a scene of the movie. If we had a perfect crafted enduring body with incredible abilities, who would we be? Do our struggles give us definition?

Or is this all so much intellectual faffing about and augmented dreamy sexy cyberpunk bodies are the actual ideal?

90


I'll let you decide that one for yourself.
 
Last edited:

gaijinkaiju

Lord Inquisitor
Sanctuary legend
Sanctuary contributor
Messages
612
Ghost in the Shell is pretty good, haven't watched it in ages though. Have been meaning to rewatch the live action adaption that was..okay.
Personally Stand Alone Complex is great too and I'd recommend watching it. Love the tachikomas.

the voice lines quite literally feel like they're being read off a piece of paper
well they are reading a script

The soundtrack is pretty good as well.
Hands down, one of the best tracks
 

Vendor-Lazarus

Arch Disciple
Sanctuary legend
Messages
937
I've seen it twice, 20 years apart, and it's okay. Just okay. Haven't seen GitS: Innocence, GitS: SAC, or GitS: A-B 1, and I'm fine with that.
 

Arnox

Master
Staff member
Founder
Messages
5,285
Love the tachikomas.
Bruh. They all got that incredibly immersion-shattering 5-year-old schoolgirl voice. On military hardware. What the fuck is that???

I've seen it twice, 20 years apart, and it's okay. Just okay. Haven't seen GitS: Innocence, GitS: SAC, or GitS: A-B 1, and I'm fine with that.
The resident sci-fi fan doesn't like Ghost in the Shell? What is this madness?

Arnox's relationship with Revy has ended.

Makoto Kusanagi is now Arnox's waifu.
I wanted to switch things up a bit, then it's back to the usual programming.
 

Vendor-Lazarus

Arch Disciple
Sanctuary legend
Messages
937
The resident sci-fi fan doesn't like Ghost in the Shell? What is this madness?
I am that, and proud of it, so I get the surprise.
I think it's too ..philosophical(?) for me. Not sure that's the exact right word. Existential, maybe.
It's the same reason I don't like Evangelion, or Battlestar Galactica & SG Universe (+drama).
 

gaijinkaiju

Lord Inquisitor
Sanctuary legend
Sanctuary contributor
Messages
612
I think it's too ..philosophical(?) for me. Not sure that's the exact right word. Existential, maybe.
I think I had a similar issue with the sequel. I remember falling asleep midway through someone giving a speech, and I've never gone back to finish it.
 
Top